There’s nothing quite like kicking it old school in New York. These six spots aren’t trying to be the next big thing. Instead, they already won, decades ago, and they’re still winning. Here’s where to catch a jazz set, take in a mural, or simply slow down in a room built long before anyone cared about turnover.
The Experience: A Night of Jazz at Bemelmans
The Neighborhood: Upper East Side
Bemelmans Bar has been the room for a proper New York night out since 1947. Ludwig Bemelmans, the author behind Madeline, painted the murals himself. In exchange, he and his family reportedly lived at The Carlyle for a year and a half. Not a bad trade. Today, a soloist takes the piano at 5:30 pm, and a jazz trio follows later in the evening. There’s a cover charge, usually $10 to $35 depending on the seat and the hour. But the real draw isn’t what’s in your glass. It’s sitting inside a room that hasn’t changed its mood in almost eighty years, listening to a set that could have happened in 1955 just as easily as tonight.
The Move: Arrive before 7 pm for the piano set, and don’t forget to look up.
The Experience: Afternoon Tea at The Palm Court, The Plaza
The Neighborhood: Midtown
The Palm Court at The Plaza has been serving afternoon tea for more than a century, and it’s still the experience most people picture when they think of this hotel. So this isn’t a trend. It’s tradition, full stop. The classic tea starts at $125 per person and includes finger sandwiches, warm scones, and a rotating selection from a 25-variety tea collection. Want to go bigger? The top-tier menu runs $235 and adds luxury teas and elaborate desserts. Reservations sell out fast, so book ahead. Also, mind the dress code: no shorts, no athletic wear, no ripped denim. This is one New York experience where dressing up is part of the point.
The Move: Book the classic tea service, and don’t forget to take advantage of the pastry.
The Experience: Farmstand Market Brunch in the Rotunda, The Pierre
The Neighborhood: Upper East Side
The Pierre’s Rotunda Room might be the single most spectacular room inside any New York hotel. Artist Edward Melcarth hand-painted the trompe l’oeil murals in 1967, and a 2016 restoration brought back their full color, sky-blue ceiling included. The best way to actually sit inside it is the Farmstand Market Brunch, served through Perrine, the hotel’s French-American restaurant, Saturdays and Sundays from 11:30 am to 4 pm. The menu shifts with the season and the market, which means it’s never quite the same brunch twice. Most guests just snap a photo of the ceiling on their way somewhere else. This is the excuse to actually sit under it.
The Move: Book a few days out if you can, and ask for a table that faces the mural.
The Experience: The Evening Ritual at King Cole Bar, The St. Regis
The Neighborhood: Midtown
Every evening at 6pm, a St. Regis butler saber-opens a bottle of Champagne beneath the King Cole Bar’s 30-foot Maxfield Parrish mural. The tradition dates back to founder John Jacob Astor, who liked marking the shift from afternoon to evening with a little theater. It’s free to watch from the bar. If you’d rather learn the technique yourself, the hotel offers a 30-minute sabering class with a bottle of Veuve Clicquot and canapés, priced at $350 for up to four people. Either way, you’re standing under the same mural where the Bloody Mary was invented in 1934, which is reason enough to stop in.
The Move: Time your visit for 6 pm sharp.
The Experience: A Visit to the Guerlain Wellness Spa, The Waldorf Astoria
The Neighborhood: Midtown East
The Waldorf Astoria reopened in July 2025 after an eight-year, $2 billion renovation, and its fifth floor now holds the largest Guerlain spa in the world. At 22,000 square feet, the Guerlain Wellness Spa matches the hotel’s scale, with treatments named for the building’s own history: The Waldorf Signature, Spirit of Achievement, Like Clockwork, Golden Hour. Prices start around $189 for a Tailor-Made Facial or Imperial Massage and climb to $600 for the two-hour Black Orchid Facial. Day access alone runs $75 for hotel guests and $150 for visitors. Before you head up, take a short detour through the Park Avenue lobby. The 148,000-piece “Wheel of Life” mosaic floor and Cole Porter’s old Steinway piano are both worth a look on your way to the elevator.
The Move: Book the Waldorf Signature treatment, and swing by the lobby mosaic before or after.
The Experience: A Historian-Led Tour of Hotel Chelsea
The Neighborhood: Chelsea
Hotel Chelsea has housed more writers, artists, and rock stars than any other building in New York, and it shows. Guided tours led by an in-house historian walk guests through the hotel’s floors, pointing out former residents’ rooms and the stories attached to them. Exposed brick, vintage fireplaces, and stained glass windows remain throughout, preserved rather than restored into something unrecognizable. It’s part architecture lesson, part ghost story, and entirely unlike touring any other hotel in the city.
The Move: Book the historian-led tour in advance and call the hotel directly, since spots are limited. Also worth a mention: the Hotel Chelsea Spa is one of the best in the city. After or before the tour, book yourself a massage, then head to brunch or dinner at their classic restaurant, Cafe Chelsea, or Lobby Bar.
Other Articles You’ll Like
Jazz in NYC: Bemelmans
Café Chelsea
The Waldorf Astoria Reopens
FAQs
Q: Do you need a reservation for the Evening Ritual at King Cole Bar?
A: No. Watching the nightly champagne sabering at 6pm is free and open to bar guests. The hands-on sabering class, though, does require booking ahead.
Q: Do you need a reservation for afternoon tea at The Palm Court?
A: Yes. Afternoon tea at The Plaza sells out regularly, so it’s best to book at least a few weeks ahead, especially around the holidays. Also, note the dress code: no shorts, sneakers, or athletic wear.
Q: Can non-hotel guests book the Guerlain Wellness Spa at The Waldorf Astoria?
A: Yes. Day access is open to visitors, not just hotel guests, though it costs more — $150 for visitors versus $75 for those staying at the hotel.
