3 Closed NYC Restaurants

We Miss Like Crazy

The days of being triple booked in an evening seem like a lifetime ago, but we’re ready to get back to life.  Or at least star making some big plans.  New York is roaring back, and all this energy is makes us miss these three closed NYC restaurants. We need the fried olives and martinis at this famed bar.  Dessert is not the same without the lemon layer cake at this hitter spot.  And the mind-blowing tasting menu of this restaurant,  is all about the glory days. These three closed NYC restaurants are our favorite NYC haunts, that we’re ready to welcome back.

The Spot:  The Grill

Why we miss it:

This is one of the closed NYC restaurants, that when it reopens, means the golden age is back. It is really nice to have a reason to dress to the nines, and the space of The Grill in the iconic Seagrams building, is always the occasion.  If there’s a restaurant that epitomizes the good old Mad Men days of martinis mid-day and power lunches, it’s The Grill.  It’s glamorous from start to finish, no matter how you cut into your $150+ Porterhouse steak.  Because the Major Food Group guys are behind the menu, the food elevates the most simple dishes like crudite in a grand presentation chilled on ice, and a caesar salad made table side.  Aside from the excellent food, we like really big baller places to remind us that we’re doing pretty well in life.

The Spot:  Polo Bar

Why we miss it:  

This is one of the closed NYC restaurants we can’t wait to have back. There is just not enough room in this article to express how much we miss the team at Polo Bar, who treat you like family, if you can slip past Ben at the front door that is.  This is not just hype either; there’s a reason why this is still the most coveted spot to score a reservation.  Polo Bar has the magic formula – the old school bar and parlor for drinks, fried olives and herbed potato chips pre-dinner, then American classics like pigs in a blanket.  The menu doesn’t take itself seriously and serves up the comfort food and the best of Americana.

Update:  Polo Bar is open for private parties.


The Spot:  Eleven Madison Park

Why we miss it:   No matter how long we experiment with recipes, or practice, practice, practice, we are never going to be able to create like they do at Eleven Madison Park.  These guys are just next level talented, from the moment you sip their molecular cocktails through the 10+ course degustation of culinary greatness.  For special occasions, or if you’re just rolling that deep to be a regular, this is the go-to spot.

Update:  This is one of the closed NYC restaurants that’s back!  But the waitlist is 15,000 people long.  Get on it now.

Previous Post
Jean Georges’s Upper East Side Restaurants
Next Post
Mother’s Day Brunch in NYC
Previous Post
Jean Georges’s Upper East Side Restaurants
Next Post
Mother’s Day Brunch in NYC




Join The List

The List

Galavante’s Picks for

Related Articles
Recent Articles

Rohan Vasa, Writer

The St. Regis Chicago Arrives

 We’re going to throw this out there: Chicago (not LA, not New York, and not Miami) has the best city hotels in the United States. And the food — well,…